Page 1 sur 1

Bug -- 2 rows formed, not allowed to choose order of removal

Message Publié : 30 Avr 2016 16:59
par Jest Phulin
In GIPF 27499, I made a move that resulted in 2 lines of 4 being formed (Jest Phulin 30/04/2016 16:46)
The basic result was this

BBBB
W
B
B
B
B

The game removed the vertical line first, leaving
_BBB
_
_
_
_
_

I had wanted to remove the horizontal line first, which would have returned more to my stock, while still capturing the white. I believe this is a bug under rule E 3.

Aussi, je suis désolé, je ne parle pas français.

Re: Bug -- 2 rows formed, not allowed to choose order of rem

Message Publié : 30 Avr 2016 18:39
par Josquin
That's game #27499? (always better to give the game's ID-number...)

Seems weird, indeed. You weren't ask to choose the line you want to remove?

Re: Bug -- 2 rows formed, not allowed to choose order of rem

Message Publié : 30 Avr 2016 23:15
par Piano
indeed, i'm very also surprised because the choice is normally proposed.

In such a case, you have to stop the game to let analyse it by an administrator.

Re: Bug -- 2 rows formed, not allowed to choose order of rem

Message Publié : 01 Mai 2016 8:46
par Jest Phulin
If I was asked to remove a line, I didn't recognize it at all, so I don't think that was the case :)

I'm not really interested in stopping the game -- ranking doesn't matter that much to delay the game to look for this bug.

Oh, and yes, it is table #27499

Re: Bug -- 2 rows formed, not allowed to choose order of rem

Message Publié : 01 Mai 2016 22:48
par Piano
Jest Phulin a écrit :I'm not really interested in stopping the game -- ranking doesn't matter that much to delay the game to look for this bug.

Actually, if there is a bug, it's important that diplojak checks to avoid this bug is occurring in the future.

Re: Bug -- 2 rows formed, not allowed to choose order of rem

Message Publié : 02 Mai 2016 4:08
par Jest Phulin
OK, sorry, I'm not sure of the workings of this site.

Does the game *need* to be stopped to look for the bug, or can the bug be traced from a replay after the game finishes?