Debunk & Grants

Debunk & Grants

Message par Volker B » 08 Oct 2017 9:24

In game 11570 round 6 Yeti debunked a theory regarding mushroom. This resolved the conflict with claw, and I got immediately the grant in center (still in Yeti's turn). I shouldn't because it was Yeti's turn, not mine. This is clarified in the FAQ secion of the Golem expansion.

My esteemed colleague and I have seals on a theory with a conflict token. During debunking, this conflict is removed. Now the theory suddenly counts for a grant. Which of us gets the grant?

Check to see if you qualify for grants only after you complete a Debunk Theory of Publish Theory action. In this particular case, you get the grant if it was your Debunk Theory action. Your colleague gets the grant if it was his or her action. And if the token was removed during someone else's action, then the grant will go to the first one who performs a Publish Theory or Debunk Theory action (even if the debunking attempt is unsuccessful).
Volker B
Premium
Premium
 
Message(s) : 12
Inscription : 08 Août 2017 8:26
Localisation : München

Re: Debunk & Grants

Message par frederic.moulis » 08 Oct 2017 11:30

well... Golem is not implemented. I can't see any error ;)
Avatar de l’utilisateur
frederic.moulis
Premium
Premium
 
Message(s) : 2881
Inscription : 15 Déc 2012 14:57
Localisation : Tours

Re: Debunk & Grants

Message par Volker B » 08 Oct 2017 11:59

OK. Thank you for the quick answer. I'll continue the game, then.
Volker B
Premium
Premium
 
Message(s) : 12
Inscription : 08 Août 2017 8:26
Localisation : München

Re: Debunk & Grants

Message par frederic.moulis » 08 Oct 2017 12:15

Honestly, I don't know what to do. If it was a base game rule, it would be present in base game FAQ. So for now, I will consider this is not a bug.
Avatar de l’utilisateur
frederic.moulis
Premium
Premium
 
Message(s) : 2881
Inscription : 15 Déc 2012 14:57
Localisation : Tours

Re: Debunk & Grants

Message par Volker B » 10 Oct 2017 20:18

Do you mean the FAQ that is somewhere in the files section on BGG? I don't know another one. I don't think that this is a much better place for these things than the last page of the expansion rulebook. Actually, the section is labeled "Fine Alchemists' Queries (about the base game)". I should have been more precise in my first post. So I think this is part of the base game, and is not related to the expansion. But, well, at the end it is your decision and your effort.
Volker B
Premium
Premium
 
Message(s) : 12
Inscription : 08 Août 2017 8:26
Localisation : München

Re: Debunk & Grants

Message par frederic.moulis » 10 Oct 2017 20:46

Well, actually, I did not mean more than "you called your source 'FAQ section of the Golem expansion'"
Now if you're telling me that it should be applied to base game, I can work on it
Avatar de l’utilisateur
frederic.moulis
Premium
Premium
 
Message(s) : 2881
Inscription : 15 Déc 2012 14:57
Localisation : Tours


Retour vers Alchemists

Qui est en ligne ?

Utilisateur(s) parcourant ce forum : Aucun utilisateur inscrit et 1 invité

cron